Cathay Pacific First Class
Image via Wikipedia

I’ve had the opportunity in the past few months of interviewing a number of distinguished thought leaders in the aviation and branding industry over the past few months on SimpliFlying. But a recent encounter in New York has left a deep impression on me, since this brand leader’s ideas truly resonated with what I’ve been writing about technology branding for airlines lately.

I’m referring to my conversation with Joe Crump, the VP of Strategy & Planning at Razorfish – the leading digital branding agency. At one point in the interview, he predicts that “any airline that doesn’t go digital pretty damn quick is going to find itself obsolete”. And he has 25 years of experience in branding and technology to back up his foresight.

Airline branding – “genuinely complicated”

In his interview, Joe shared that the fundamental problem of the airline industry is that “of over-promising and then inconsistently delivering”. And this is mainly because of the number of externalities airlines need to deal with – from fluctuating oil prices to severe weather conditions – all of which often impact the business negatively. Ultimately, it’s detrimental to the brand and makes airline branding “full of rich challenges”.

Expanding the brand “beyond the browser”

Joe also discloses that the “least important part of brand building is how you talk about it”. It’s the brand experience that matters most, and in case of airlines, begins much before a passenger steps on the plane. These days, it starts on the Internet. Joe believes that airlines cannot afford to have stale websites anymore, as they’re competing against the likes of Apple and Coke, when it comes to delivering an online brand experience.

He shares that airlines like Virgin America, JetBlue, Southwest and Ryanair are setting new benchmarks in web interaction. Personally, I’ve had great experiences with Cathay Pacific as well. But most of these airlines are pretty agile and generally young, without legacy baggage.

Joe’s advise for legacy carriers is that they need to renew their culture by imbibing a spirit of innovation across the airline. An example of this he gives is that of American Airlines adopting Go-Go for providing wifi in the air.

Without revealing much more about the man and his ideas, let me jump straight to the interview. Below, you’ll find the first of three parts of Joe’s interview. The other two parts of his interview will be posted on SimpliFlying on 21st and 23rd January.

 

What are your thoughts on Joe’s analysis? Do you agree with him, and my earlier assessment that airlines need to go digital with their brands? What’re some examples of airlines succeeding at such efforts, and failing too?

Reblog this post [with Zemanta]
  • Glenn Campbell
    Couldn't agree more, in fact I can't think of any "feel good" branding (at least in my market area), just price specials that only undermine the value of the carrier long term.
  • Bradut Florescu
    Yes, that is right. Needless to say that there are so many airlines that start up with an on line structured brand identity.
  • Ron Verweij
    Fully Agree. I have been talking to a friend of mine who owns a marketing platform used by 2 airlines and he have showed me some insights. With pressure on costs their e-commerce / digital branding will be giving Airlines a healthy profit. My fear though is that Airlines forget about their core business since the e-commerce part of Airlines is somehow deattached from ground services / inflight services. The challenge is not to loose focus and integrate mobile commerce with the mobile boarding pass as primary driver. Why the mobile baording pass? Well with adding this the mobile channel is added to the online services and enables Airlines to build a one-on-one relation from packing to arrival.

    Regards,
    Ron Verweij
  • Spyro Poulos
    But I mean isn't that the case with any brand - in fact I still can't believe how long it took even media based brands like newspapers and magazines to go digital - it's one of the reasons print is in trouble because we all didn't take digital expansion of our brands seriously back in '95.
  • David Taylor
    Is Joe suggesting that the Internet will be crucial to the future success of airline brands? (Or any others?) I'm shocked! On one hand he says that what you say about the brand is least important, yet on the other accuses the airlines of over-promising. Airlines have been hammered by 9/11, out of control fuel costs, and now a major recession. This is what's eating away at their brands.
  • Marie-José Jamin
    Joe should consider some external factors that have hit the aviation industry the past year, like David points out.
    On the other hand it is kind of weird to state that brands have to go digital as late as 2009.
    Becoming digital is easy. Just ask some neighbourhood kids to design a website, or hire one of the many, many companies that do this professionally. But being digital is much, much more than that first step.
    Without a solid strategy how to make this complex, fast changing digital environment work for your brand, how to adept your company to this situation (response time, crises, marketing tools, sales tools, reporting tools, customer criticism, ideas, product development, management) can result in over promising, overspending en uncontrollable mess many companies are dealing with right now and of which even airlines think that this is too much.
  • Jonathan Paisner
    if "going digital" means giving consumers a reason to positively interact with your brand online, absolutely. Airlines must create opportunities for two-way communication with their consumers - and not just by using a website to sell them stuff but to offer content and insights that consumers care about. If they don't they will further commoditize their offering by becoming merely a logo next to the cheapest price that can be found on orbitz. jetblue offers a solid purchase experience - plus a relatively easy to use and understand frequent flier program that rewards direct online purchase. their strong digital presence drives consumers to interact directly with the brand, rather than rely on third parties and aggregators.
    jpaisner@ hotmail.com
  • Mohammed Thiab
    Contrary to the IT business, airlines and aviation is a very mature industry, driven clearly by business needs and not by technology bells and whistles. In airlines industry, the stakes are high and this has more than just financial implications when/if things go dramatically wrong. Airlines is mission-critical and also also time-sensitive. Safety and high reputation/image are also critical to the success or failure of an airlines company.

    Simply put, success criteria of an airlines can be extracted from the main mission which could be "To fly people and goods from point A to point B SAFELY and ON-SCHEDULE while maintaining a reasonable level of COMFORT and CARE to the passegers.

    Other than that would be cosmetics including food variety, on-board entertainment, charming stewardesses, color of their dresses, digital logos, ... etc.

    Mentioning digital logos. They can be useful as a branding tool, but after ensuring all other critical success factors are satisfactorily addressed and met.

    My 0.02 thoughts on this topic
  • Tom Scrabala
    There are no "thought leaders" in airline branding. A good website does not make for a positive brand experience.
blog comments powered by Disqus

Copyright © 2010 - Simpliflying